New Study: More Reliable Power Would Cut Outages by 90% and Save Texans Billions in the Next Major Winter Storm
On today’s path, a 1-in-10-year winter storm would bring more than 40 hours of outages and nearly $11 billion in added energy costs. Building more natural gas power would cut the power families lose by nearly 90%.
AUSTIN — A major winter storm in 2030, the kind Texas can expect about once a decade, would leave families facing more than 40 hours of power outages and nearly $11 billion in added energy costs in a single week if the state keeps building its grid around wind, solar, and batteries, according to a new study from the Texas Public Policy Foundation’s Life:Powered initiative.
The study, Forecasting the Future of the ERCOT Grid, Part 2: Solving the Winter Reliability Challenge, by Michael Reed and Brent Bennett, also points to a fix. Shifting about 12.5 GW of planned new generation from wind and solar to natural gas would cut the amount of power Texans lose by nearly 90%, with most of the remaining shortfalls confined to small parts of the state. That would save roughly $12 billion in energy costs and economic losses from a single storm, while keeping market prices stable in normal weather.
“Every Texas family remembers Winter Storm Uri: the power losses during the storm and the rising electricity bills that followed,” said Brent Bennett, policy director for Life:Powered. “Wind and solar can’t be counted on in a long freeze, and batteries run down in hours. The grid that keeps families safe and warm in a storm is also the one that protects their wallets.”
Over the past five years, ERCOT added 36 GW of solar, 22 GW of storage, and 10 GW of wind, but only 4 GW of new natural gas. This imbalance is caused by the way that ERCOT’s market pays every power source the same price, whether or not it can deliver when families need it most. Federal tax credits for wind and solar have further exacerbated the problem.
ERCOT’s upcoming triennial reliability assessment gives the Public Utility Commission a timely chance to consider market reforms that better value reliable, long-duration power vs. variable power and short-duration storage. The authors also urge the Legislature to pass legislation that sets a reliability standard for all generators so that wind and solar compete in the market on equal footing with reliable generation.
The full study is available here.