Every Friday morning, I join the Cardle & Woolley Show on Talk1370 Radio in Austin to announce the week’s Winners & Losers. After seven days filled with grounded planes, Outlook crashing, bank communications blocked and the NSA dropping off the grid—which we are assured is all coincidental—at least the radio waves are working. Here’s who made the list:
LOSER: Houston Chronicle — Now They Tell Us
AI estimates that during the run-up to the election, the Houston Chronicle published close to 30 articles slanted against the public education reforms put in place by Republicans over the last decade. That doesn’t count more than a dozen editorials demanding the state stop reporting that schools are failing, and denouncing the horror of requiring children to learn the story of Noah and the Ark.
But now that the election is over, the Houston Chronicle put out a story this week reporting that many education experts are urging Gov-elect Gina Hinojosa to “think twice” before scrapping many of Texas’ public education reforms.
Hinojosa ran on a platform that included getting rid of the STAAR test, ending A-F grading of public schools and ending the system that incentivizes teachers based on performance. She also pledged to stop state intervention into failing schools. But the public education “experts” interviewed by the Houston Chronicle (who all likely support Democrats) say they are worried that if Hinojosa moves forward with her agenda, Texas could lose its unique focus on positive student outcomes which is the bedrock of every conservative reform.
Teachers’ unions hate the state system of grading schools with an A-F based on their performance. They also hate the STAAR test, which determines whether students are acquiring basic skills. Hinojosa has vowed to get rid of both, but Lori Taylor, at Texas A&M, counsels against that, saying that although the tests may have flaws, “you can’t cure the patient if you’re taking away the thermometers. You have to have some measure of achievement.”
Matthew Kraft, an education professor at Brown University in Ohio, agreed saying it would be a “major mistake to uproot statewide testing” in Texas without a plan to replace it. Kraft also praised Texas’ Teacher Incentive Allotment program that determines teacher pay raises on effectiveness, rather than on the years they’ve worked or degrees they have obtained. Jacob Kirksey, an education professor at Texas Tech, has studied the incentive pay program and says, unequivocally, that it works: “It’s improved student achievement statewide for those participating districts.”
As for state takeover of failing schools, even incoming Texas House Speaker Senfronia Thompson, D-Houston, says the state intervention at Houston Independent School District, which included a number of schools that had been failing for at least five years, has improved outcomes for students there. The Texas Education Agency says the percentage of students reading and doing math at grade level at HISD has increased from 39% to 51%.
So far, Hinojosa does not appear to be moved. She insists she wants to stop programs that pay good teachers more, saying incentives put too much pressure on teachers who already have a tough job. She also wants to return failing schools to local control, reversing the gains that have been made by state intervention. She has called Education Freedom Accounts a scam, causing parents of disabled children to speak out this week urging her not to gut the program. Those parents say it has been “life-changing” for disabled children. In fact, most everybody loves the state’s transformational public education policies except the teachers’ unions. Hinojosa will have to decide whose side she is on.
WINNERS/LOSERS: Voices from the Blue Wave
Texas is still in a honeymoon period with the incoming Democrat regime, while conservatives are parsing every word of new leaders to determine exactly what they mean. Giving grace is always in order—but we are also the “trust but verify” team, so there’s a thumbs up rather than a cheer that Gov.-elect Gina Hinosoja reported she’d had a good conversation with President Donald Trump and assured him that she shared his commitment to keeping the border secure. Great! Texans are certainly down with that. Of course, her view of how that happens likely differs from his, so stay tuned.
Meanwhile, U.S. Senator-elect James Talarico told a cheering crowd in Denver this week that he wants to bring back a new “Great Society…the dream of an America where everyone can fulfill their God-given potential…a more perfect union.”
Apparently Talarico doesn’t know what happened the last time Democrats gave us a “Great Society,” which most experts believe dramatically deepened the cycle of urban poverty and was a major factor in the destruction of the family—particularly the Black family, which we are still trying to reverse.
Democrat Daniel Patrick Moynihan documented all this at the time and economics professor Thomas Sowell has been writing about it eloquently for decades. Perhaps Talarico missed this while studying government at the University of Texas or education at Harvard.
Not nearly as much grace is required for State Rep. Gene Wu, D-Houston, who said this week that Texan Elon Musk should be investigated and prosecuted, but when he was asked for what crime, Wu said he didn’t know—although he did speculate that Musk could be a traitor. Wu is chairman of the House Democratic Caucus, but he is being challenged for that position by Christina Morales, also a Houston Democrat, who was ranked the most liberal member of the Texas House last year by the regular rankers at Rice University. This will be fun to watch.
LOSER: What Happened Part 2 — More Data Rolls In
The losers usually provide the most immediate election analysis, and conservatives from all over the country are continuing to pour over the voting results from the Nov. 3 midterms. The people at August Strategies have done the latest tally and report that Republicans lost 622 state legislative seats while Democrats gained 563 seats. Democrats gained both legislative chambers and the governors office in six states, while Republicans hold control of the State Senate in Texas.
They also compiled an update on the ballot measures that passed. Five states banned boys playing in girls sports and four states instituted caps on income and property taxes, although Colorado voted down an income tax cap and Washington increased taxes on incomes over $1 million. Alabama passed legislation protecting school prayer and the pledge of allegiance, and Idaho made English the official language in public schools.
Meanwhile, pollsters at Cygnal released the most extensive post-mortem survey yet after talking to 3,000 voters two days after the election. They concluded that half the Democratic shift creating the national Blue Wave came from people who had voted for Trump in 2024, and the other half came from the massive increase of new voters on the Democrat side. Take a look at all their findings here, but a couple of interesting data points stood out.
First, 51% of voters want Congress to work with Trump, including 21% of Democrats. Only 40% want a check on him.
Also, many are saying that the GOP defeat came because Republicans failed to discuss affordability issues, but the Cygnal survey found that candidates did talk about those issues, but nobody cared. To quote their findings: “inflation and gas ads reached everyone and moved no one in particular.”
WINNER: Cell Phone Bans in Schools (We Told You So)
TPPF strongly backed HB 1481 in 2025, which bans cell phones in public school classrooms bell to bell. The only pushback came from Northeast ISD in San Antonio, which stomped its proverbial feet, tantrum style, essentially saying, “you are not the boss of us.” The NEISD school board managed to delay implementation of the cell phone ban for a year until the Texas Education Agency stepped in and forced them to get the kids’ phones out of the classrooms. Now we know that obstinance was an injustice and a setback for their students.
A new study from the Harvard Center for Education Policy Research found that students’ learning growth in math and reading significantly improved in schools with strict cell phone bans. The researchers say that it has reversed half the annual decline in achievement before the pandemic. Most states have banned cell phones in classrooms, and stricter guidelines are being put forward to make student focus and concentration the priority. One more thing Texas got right.
LOSER: College Football Playoff Selection Committee
For many Americans, College GameDay every Saturday provides immediate proof that no matter how bad things get in Washington, we won’t lose the country. From the Big House to The Swamp, the Longhorns, the Red Raiders, even the 12th Man, America is cheering on games where tradition cements families and communities. And merit—not political ideology or grievance—is all that matters.
That’s why the College Football Playoff (CFP) rankings have created a huge breach of trust in the last couple weeks, undermining one of our most important American institutions. The CFP Selection Committee is just making it up as they go along.
How can the CFP rank Alabama (8–2) five places ahead of Tennessee which defeated them 26 to 10 a month ago? Alabama also ranked higher than undefeated UCLA (10–0) and one-loss Indiana (9–1). Texas has the same 8-2 record and has beaten five ranked opponents, but they are two spots below Alabama on the CFP bracket. There is simply no way to explain that other than some strange bias for the Crimson Tide. The CFP is also squeezing out Texas Tech (9-1) which just demolished Oklahoma State—which is not nobody. Currently, Tech at No. 12, would be the first team to be cut. Meanwhile, Indiana, the defending champions, fell five points last week and they didn’t even play.
America’s democracy will easily survive the current Blue Wave, but the Founding Fathers didn’t build any checks and balances into the CFP Selection Committee. They are creating huge cracks in our faith in college football at a time when we need it most, by admittedly substituting their subjective judgment over scores, wins and losses.
In the age of AI, how can we let a dozen people just go with their gut? The stakes are high. We are talking about the football games that will provide the backdrop for family and community celebrations of Christmas and New Year’s across the country. There needs to be an immediate reset, and the CFP needs to get it right.
This week, No. 5 ranked Texas, coming off its last-second, heart-stopping victory against LSU last Saturday, will play Arkansas tomorrow afternoon in Austin. No. 12 ranked Texas Tech will play Baylor. Hook ‘em and Wreck ‘em.
Have a great weekend!
Listen to Winners & Losers on Talk 1370, the Cardle & Woolley show, every Friday morning at 8:30 a.m. Here’s the listen live link.
Sign up to receive the weekly newsletter at www.texaspolicy.com/9thandCongress.
Follow Sherry on X @sylvester1630 and find her on Substack at sherrysylvester.substack.com.
Sherry Sylvester is a Distinguished Senior Fellow at the Texas Public Policy Foundation and the former Senior Advisor to Texas Lt. Governor Dan Patrick.