Can a city ban you from renting your home—even when its own studies show short-term rentals aren’t a problem at all?

Welcome back to Rightly Decided, the mostly originalist takes of the litigators of the Texas Public Policy Foundation! In this special off-season episode, Laura Beth Latimer, Chance Weldon, and Nathan Seltzer welcome TPPF alum Christian Townsend of the Pacific Legal Foundation to talk short-term rentals—and why these cases aren’t really about short-term rentals at all.

The team previews the Supreme Court of Texas oral argument in City of Dallas v. Dallas Short-Term Rental Alliance (December 3), unpacks the original meaning of Texas’s “due course of the law of the land” clause. They also introduce TPPF’s pending cert petition to the U.S. Supreme Court in Marfil v. City of New Braunfels, where the Fifth Circuit held that evidence is “wholly beside the point” under rational basis review.

If courts won’t look at the facts, what’s left of your property rights? And which circuits will prevail in this circuit split?
  • 0:00 – Intro & the Ghost of Christian Townsend: Welcoming our PLF guest and teeing up a big month for short-term rental litigation.
  • 2:40 – The Dallas Ordinance: The city’s own studies found no link between short-term rentals and nuisances—so Dallas passed one of the most restrictive bans in the country anyway.
  • 6:20 – Zaatari v. City of Austin: From the founders’ weekly rentals to the Green Book, plus Austin’s infamous 10:00 PM “bedtime” for adult guests and TPPF’s first merits win.
  • 12:05 – The Two-Step Test: How a due course of law claim works at the preliminary injunction stage.
  • 14:20 – Due Course of the Law of the Land: Why Texas’s 1876 Constitution, written after the Slaughterhouse Cases, protects more than federal due process.
  • 20:20 – Slicing the Right to Lease: Why courts carving property into ever-thinner sticks would never fly for the First or Second Amendment.
  • 25:20 – The Police Power, Properly Understood: Sic utere tuo ut alienum non laedas—use your property in ways that don’t harm your neighbor.
  • 29:20 – Does Evidence Matter? Yates v. Milwaukee and why courts don’t have to accept a city’s say-so that something is a nuisance.
  • 30:45 – Beyond Short-Term Rentals: PLF’s challenge on behalf of Texas nurse practitioners and the eyebrow threaders in Patel.
  • 38:20 – Property Owners as the Minority: Why “go to the democratic process” fails the people who need constitutional protection most.
  • 40:35 – The Housing Affordability Myth: What actually drives housing costs (hint: it’s not STRs).
  • 45:05 – Marfil v. City of New Braunfels: Neighbors of Schlitterbahn, grandfathered rentals, and a city rationale that both raises and lowers property values.
  • 48:35 – The Fifth Circuit’s Rulings: A right to lease “for less than 30 days” and evidence that’s “wholly beside the point.”
  • 53:00 – Blue Houses & Flood Control: What rational basis looks like when no evidence is allowed.
  • 54:40 – The Circuit Split: The Fifth and Seventh Circuits vs. the Second, Sixth, Eighth, Ninth, and Tenth—and what we’re asking SCOTUS to do.
  • 58:20 – Why It Matters to Everyone: Rational basis governs almost everything the government does.

Subscribe to Rightly Decided on Apple or Spotify.