Date Filed: November 17, 2026
Original Court:UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF WYOMING
Case Status: Pending
Joshua Smunk is a Wyoming resident and owner of Hooves, Horns & Hideaways, an outdoor recreation business offering guided tours, hunting services, and pack llama rentals. The BlueRibbon Coalition is a nonprofit organization dedicated to protecting and expanding public access to recreational opportunities on public lands. Both regularly visit federally designated wilderness areas and produce videos documenting their outdoor activities.
In September 2025, Smunk participated in a 14-day elk hunt in Wyoming’s Shoshone National Forest. The hunt was filmed by another participant and subsequently published on YouTube. During the video, Smunk’s pack llamas appeared on camera, and another participant mentioned his llama rental business. Although Smunk neither published nor monetized the video, U.S. Forest Service officials later accused him of violating the Wilderness Act of 1964, which prohibits commercial enterprises in designated wilderness areas. Officials argued that the appearance of his llamas constituted commercial advertising and that the video’s monetization violated federal law.
In subsequent communications, Forest Service officials informed Smunk that videos filmed in wilderness areas could not be monetized, even after the footage was recorded. Officials also warned that the agency actively monitors social media for potential violations and pursues enforcement against individuals who publish commercial content. Under the government’s interpretation, individuals who film otherwise permissible videos in wilderness areas could face fines, imprisonment, or restrictions on accessing public lands simply because their footage generates revenue or references a business.
The Wilderness Act was enacted to preserve the natural character of federally designated wilderness areas by restricting commercial enterprises and activities that could physically alter protected landscapes. TPPF argues that the Forest Service has exceeded its statutory authority by interpreting those restrictions to prohibit constitutionally protected speech. The lawsuit further contends that the agency lacks authority to regulate activities occurring outside federal wilderness areas, including the subsequent publication and monetization of videos on social media platforms.
TPPF is challenging the Forest Service’s interpretation of the Wilderness Act under the Administrative Procedure Act and the First Amendment. The lawsuit argues that distinguishing between permissible personal videos and prohibited commercial videos based on their content or monetization constitutes an unconstitutional restriction on free speech. Filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Wyoming, the case seeks declaratory and injunctive relief preventing the Forest Service from enforcing these restrictions. A favorable ruling would protect the ability of outdoor enthusiasts, businesses, and nonprofit organizations to document and share their experiences on public lands without facing federal penalties simply because their videos generate revenue.
Case Documents: